No one’s talking about a dangerous new US housing trend. Why home equity agreements could trigger disaster for millions

No one’s talking about a dangerous new US housing trend. Why home equity agreements could trigger disaster for millions

Vishesh Raisinghani

Sun, December 7, 2025 at 8:30 AM EST

5 min read

American families collectively have a jaw-dropping $35.8 trillion in home equity as of mid-2025, according to the Federal Reserve (1). Unfortunately, much of that immense wealth is relatively illiquid and difficult to access.

Perhaps the most popular way to tap into your home equity — besides selling the house — is a home equity line of credit (HELOC). However, there’s been a surge in demand for a new financial instrument that promises to give you access to your home equity without “interest rates” or “monthly payments.”

Must Read

Thanks to Jeff Bezos, you can now become a landlord for as little as $100 — and no, you don't have to deal with tenants or fix freezers. Here's how
Dave Ramsey warns nearly 50% of Americans are making 1 big Social Security mistake — here’s what it is and 3 simple steps to fix it ASAP
I’m almost 50 years old and have nothing saved for retirement. What do I do? Don’t panic. Here are 6 easy ways to catch up (and fast)

Home equity agreements (HEA) or home equity investments (HEI) contracts have been gaining traction as an alternative to traditional HELOCs. But the finer print on these complex agreements reveals why their growing popularity could be putting many vulnerable homeowners at risk.

Understanding home equity agreements

As the name suggests, a HEA is a financial agreement that offers homeowners up-front cash in exchange for some of their home equity. The agreement usually involves a fixed term (such as 15 years) after which the homeowner must repay the up-front cash along with a multiple of their home’s value at the time of settlement.

Since this isn’t a typical loan, many homeowners are tempted by the appeal of receiving cash without a monthly interest payment or credit check. This could be why these contracts have become more popular in recent years, according to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB).

In the first ten months of 2024, 11,000 home equity contracts collectively worth an estimated $1.1 billion were signed. The total market is estimated to be somewhere between $2 and $3 billion (2).

Although this niche market is still considerably smaller than that for HELOCs, the CFPB expects it to continue growing for the foreseeable future. But the underlying complexity of these agreements could be exposing homeowners to more risk than they appreciate.

Read More: Here are the 5 market moves you can't ignore heading into 2026 — and what savvy investors are doing now to prepare

Multiple potential pitfalls

Although HEAs seem like simple equity-sharing agreements on the surface, digging deeper reveals just how favorable the terms are for the company issuing these contracts.

Story Continues

For starters, the up-front cash payment often involves a fee for the homeowner, often 3% to 5%, according to CFPB. That reduces the amount of cash you actually receive. Meanwhile, the contract often involves several features to protect the issuer from downside risks. For instance, the multiplier used to calculate settlement is often higher than the ratio of home equity the homeowner gets paid for.

For example, notes CFPB, a homeowner could sign an agreement to receive cash for 10% of their home’s equity but the contract applies a 2x multiplier, which means they must pay 20% of the home’s long-term appreciation (2). Not only is such an arrangement unfavorable for the homeowner, it also means the home would have to lose significant value before the issuer faces any losses.

Some HEA contracts can also underestimate the value of the home during the up-front payment. For instance, the contract could estimate your home’s value at $450,000 even though you’re likely to get $500,000 on the market, which effectively locks in a sizable payout for the issuer.

The complexity of these contracts can make it easier to miss these features. Unsuspecting homeowners who do not carefully review and negotiate the terms of these agreements could end up paying far more for a HEA than a traditional HELOC.

The bottom line

The market for home equity agreements is rapidly expanding, as more homeowners are drawn to the appeal of easy cash without interest rates or monthly payments. At first glance, these agreements might sound like a better deal than borrowing against the value of your property.

But the structure of these agreements can put homeowners at a disadvantage. When you run the numbers, you could discover that a HEA is more expensive over the long run than a traditional HELOC.

“Under many contracts,” notes CFPB (2), “the settlement amount grows at a rate of 19.5% to 22% per year in the early years, which is substantially higher than interest rates on most home-secured credit.”

No one’s talking about a dangerous new US housing trend. Why home equity agreements could trigger disaster for millions